Posts

Showing posts with the label industry

Award Shows are Good Actually

Image
  The Ennie awards have just been awarded for another years, and as is tradition, this means that there has been a load of chatter about award shows and their merits. This year saw a bumper crop of nominees , including several of my Blogger colleagues . Some of them even won! While I hesitate to claim total Blogging cultural victory, we're getting there. The Ennies are of course not the only award concerned with TTRPGs - there are also the Diana Jones award , the Sprinties , the Rammies , The Awards ,, the CRIT awards , the Bloggies , and the Lizzies (as well as various categories in other awards, like the Origins Awards and the Nebulas , and I am sure I am missing some). Most award shows bill themselves as recognising and rewarding excellence in their field, which is a noble goal, but also almost entirely subjective. Excellence according to whom? In awards decided by a panel of judges, it will always be according to their opinions, with or without a judging rubric, and when y...

The Price of Words: Valuing a PDF

Image
  Recently, there has been discourse on the social medias about the prices we pay (or perhaps rather, do not pay) for our RPG PDFs, including the thread by Chris Bissette of LootTheRoom, and a sternly worded blogpost from Ramona of Alderdoodle. Discussing the value of RPGs is of course something I have done before , and every time I see this discourse, I am tempted to get involved (as indeed I sometimes do ). However, I find that my opinions on this issue are too nuanced to be neatly presented in a series of social media posts, hence, a blog post. Another few bits of preamble that I would like to make clear, is that I don't want to dispute what Chris and Ramona are saying. They run tabletop businesses, I do not. I am just a customer and hobbyist creator. Probably the kind who ought to buy more PDFs. An Outside Look a the Landscape Let's start with an assumption that we can hopefully all agree upon: A professional RPG writer designer deserves to be compensated fairly for the...

Against value propositions

Image
Bear with me folks, I'm going to do a discourse. Nobody asked for my thoughts, but what is a personal blog, if not a soap box for me to yell them out anyway. As always, but this time in particular, feel free to tell me that I'm wildly off base, and the things I say are bad are good actually. Recently, I read a post on Gaby Fermi's excellent blog, rolling d6 (go read it, it's good), about the price of tabletop RPGs . Here, she argues that RPG books are not too expensive because they offer a good value proposition in terms of how many hours of fun you can get from a book. While I solidly agree with her conclusion: No, RPG books are not too expensive, I'm not a huge fan of her reasoning to get there. As a preamble, I will just acknowledge that I am writing this from the relatively privileged position of having a job that gives me enough disposable income to buy many more games than I will ever have time to play. I understand that people with lower incomes will of cou...

The Book is the Game is an Object

Image
  Christmas has come, and is well on its way to going, as I write this. It's nice spending time with family and eating yourself fat etc, but that's not the topic of this blog. As part of our Christmas celebrations, I received several nice RPG books as gifts, which got me thinking of The Book as An Object. There has been a lot of discussion about what "the game is", is it what's written in the book, does it only exist at the table (whether wooden or virtual), or is it some abstract space defined by the written rules? An interesting, if academic, question, but not one I will attempt to answer here, except to say that the RPG book serves multiple purposes. There is a discussion about information design that often rears its head: Is it better to design the book for someone sitting down and reading it, or for someone referencing it at the table during play? And is it possible to design for both simultaneously? Many games try to solve this with play aids at the table in...

Kickstarter FOMO and the Content Firehose

Image
      I will preface this with the fact that I am not an industry analyst. I am not looking at any hard data here, relying instead only on my own anecdotal personal experience, and vibes. I look at enough data at work, I'm not going to do it now. There is a great mismatch in the heart of the TTRPG hobby, in fact there may be more than one. I am talking about the mismatch between the "products" being written and bought, and those being played. You could even add in the intermediate stage of being read. Most of us are limited in the amount of products we buy by money, and all of us are limited in reading and playing by time. For non-solo efforts, play has the additional complicating factor of getting schedules to align, meaning that in general, fewer games are played than read, and for some (including myself), fewer books are read than bought. And yet, I there are many books I would like to buy (or have supported in crowdfunding), but have (probably) wisely skipped or postp...