Posts

Showing posts with the label theory

The Game is Made of Holes

Image
  The fruitful void, whitespace, rules-lite, et cetera. A set of role-playing rules will often be like a Swiss cheese: Some overarching rules to provide structure, and holes to fill at the table. When designing a game, you must choose the scope and specificity of the rules. You probably need to (perhaps metaphorically) write down at least  one  rule for what you're making to be considered a game (though you may convince me otherwise), and conversely, there is a limit to how many rules you can write down if you intend to finish writing within your lifetime. When then, is the correct amount of rules? Surely this must be a solved problem in the field of game design. The correct answer is of course whatever you think it is. We play game to have fun, or at least some kind of desired experience. If a game provides that without you feeling chafed under the weight of the rulebook, or lost in a big, empty or not very fruitful void, then the game has the right amount of rules for y...

On Treasure in Holes

Image
  It is a truth universally acknowledged that a destitute adventurer, in possession of a sharp blade, must be in want of a hole. Holes are after all where the treasures live, guarded by orcs and worse. Of course, in modern parlance, we like to call these holes "Dungeons", and if we want to get real fancy, they're "The Mythic Underworld". This is because, indeed, it does not make sense that one would store that much treasure in what is, essentially, a hole in the ground. Even at the best of times, going underground is a scary prospect, untold tonnes of earth and stone hanging over your head, ready to collapse at any moment if not properly secured, burying you with your treasure for all eternity. Sensible people build castles, it's less work. Maybe a little basement underneath, but none of this deep cave stuff. That's delving too deep, too greedily. This means that normal people don't put their treasures in big dungeons deep underground. People with lo...

Touched by the Fay: 20 Advancements for Cairn and other Fantasy Games

Image
Liden Gunver og Havmanden , 1841, Edvard Lehmann Like all good recipe bloggers, I have added a big preamble about why I wrote this, and my thoughts on Cairn 2e backgrounds. If you just want the advancements, scroll down! I have been reading the Cairn 2e books (more on that in a later blogpost), and something about Cairn that has always been frustrating me a bit is the lack of special traits or similar to make characters unique, rather than blank slates defined only by their items and a handful of stats, and whatever the player puts into them. For a long time, people have told me, "Cairn 2e backgrounds fixes this", and I have stubbornly told them, "I will read that when I get my box set, then." Lo and behold, my box arrived a few weeks ago, and indeed, some of the backgrounds contains what I want. But only a few of them, and often just as one or two entries on the roll table. Many backgrounds contains the kind of abilities or traits I want, but tie them to items with...

What is the Game, and What Makes a Good System?

Image
  In a confluence of events, I ran my first session of Mothership this week, after having played it most weeks for the last six months or so, coinciding with the Paul Beakley of Indie Game Reading Club posting his review of the game. I think it is a well articulated critique, echoing some points made in Dwiz' review over on Knight at the Opera (now sadly unavailable). However, as a self-professed "system-curious indie guy", I think Paul underestimates the value of a simple but effective chassis (or at least, he comes to the conclusion that it is not what he wants out of a game). The strength of the stress system is how simple it is to interact with - yes, the rules in the booklet may not be enough to fully drive play on their own, but perhaps that was never the intention? I would argue that the core rules of Mothership offer just half of the game, with the other half left open to be filled by modules or an enterprising game master: The quality of the rules should the...

Fight, Loot, Die, Repeat: Bringing Roguelikes to the Tabletop

Image
  Inspired by a discussion in the RTFM Discord, I have decided to write up some thoughts on how the properties of a modern "roguelike" video game could be adapted to a tabletop RPG. Of course, there is a whole nomenclature discussion to be had about modern "roguelikes" greatly differ from the original Rogue and its likes Angband , Zangband , etc. and is now essentially just a marketing term. However, I will nevertheless root this in modern "roguelike" conventions, as the originals could essentially be emulated by just playing an OSR dungeon crawl . Let us first define the specific genre conventions that we wish to emulate: Gameplay structured around short-ish "runs". You always start at the beginning of the "generalised dungeon" and make your way deeper until you either die or succeed in vanquishing the final boss.  Dying rather than succeeding is the expected outcome for the first many runs. There is no going back to town to resupply...

Trimming the Fat: Goodbye Classes, Hello Skills and Feats

Image
It's no secret that I kind of like the bones of the 5e skill system, even if that implementation is flawed. I also think that 5e is a clunky, bloated system, but I do understand its appeal. Making your little Blorbo is fun! Some discussion in the Discord server hosted by Prismatic Wasteland prompted me to expand upon my own thoughts on building characters through skills, stats, and feats, in lieu of traditional classes. In particular the focus of this blogpost will be on how I am for character building to work in my upcoming game Mistwalker (which I have mentioned before ), similar to how Josh wrote about his design thoughts while working on His Majesty the Worm . As in 5e, I do want  players to make their little Blorbos in Mistwalker, but I find that relying on a 5e-style (what some would undoubtedly call " trad ") leads to too much overhead, as well as a very prescriptive, and thus limiting, set of character options. In particular when it comes to advancement. I like...

Against value propositions

Image
Bear with me folks, I'm going to do a discourse. Nobody asked for my thoughts, but what is a personal blog, if not a soap box for me to yell them out anyway. As always, but this time in particular, feel free to tell me that I'm wildly off base, and the things I say are bad are good actually. Recently, I read a post on Gaby Fermi's excellent blog, rolling d6 (go read it, it's good), about the price of tabletop RPGs . Here, she argues that RPG books are not too expensive because they offer a good value proposition in terms of how many hours of fun you can get from a book. While I solidly agree with her conclusion: No, RPG books are not too expensive, I'm not a huge fan of her reasoning to get there. As a preamble, I will just acknowledge that I am writing this from the relatively privileged position of having a job that gives me enough disposable income to buy many more games than I will ever have time to play. I understand that people with lower incomes will of cou...

The Book is the Game is an Object

Image
  Christmas has come, and is well on its way to going, as I write this. It's nice spending time with family and eating yourself fat etc, but that's not the topic of this blog. As part of our Christmas celebrations, I received several nice RPG books as gifts, which got me thinking of The Book as An Object. There has been a lot of discussion about what "the game is", is it what's written in the book, does it only exist at the table (whether wooden or virtual), or is it some abstract space defined by the written rules? An interesting, if academic, question, but not one I will attempt to answer here, except to say that the RPG book serves multiple purposes. There is a discussion about information design that often rears its head: Is it better to design the book for someone sitting down and reading it, or for someone referencing it at the table during play? And is it possible to design for both simultaneously? Many games try to solve this with play aids at the table in...

Matters of Luck and Skill - Reframing the Skill Check

Image
  A common type of resolution mechanic in tabletop role playing games is the skill check - often resolved with comparing the value of a dice role plus a skill bonus to a target number ( E.g. difficulty class/DC, actual terminology may differ). The value of the DC tells you the difficulty of the task ahead, and the larger the character's skill bonus, the higher the chance of rolling over the DC and succeeding at the task. This framing essentially positions the roll as determining how well the character does at the task, which can feel unsatisfying when a character who should be skilled at the task fails something relatively simple (you could of course argue that relatively simple tasks should not warrant a roll, but you have to draw a line somewhere if you want to have skill checks in your game, and I like skills). One option is of course to forego the dice roll completely - select a difficulty class and compare it to a "skill level", if the skill is higher, it's a suc...

Blog Friday: Abstract away your wealth!

Image
  One of the staples of old school play is gold for XP. I don't use it myself, because I don't particularly like it. This dislike comes down to main issues: I don't like counting XP, and I don't like counting gold (or silver, copper, or any other currency). In this blog post, I behave much like a cooking blogger, ruminating a bit on my thoughts before presenting something gameable at the end. If you just want the game juice, skip to the section just before the bullet points. In my mind, XP is by far the easiest of the two to get rid of in a satisfying way. Just level up whenever it makes sense, such as after looting the dungeon, slaying the dragon, saving the prince(ss), etc. or just throw levels out entirely and rely on diegetic advancement instead.  Money however, has the problem that it is already entirely diegetic. The money is normally tracked as it exists in the world, not as some external game currency. Adventurers need money to spend on survival, buying trinkets...

Brief thoughts on implied settings

Image
  I finally found the time to read Nova's post on hyperdiegesis , which, among other things, has taught me a new word. I love implied settings in fiction, and Nova cites some of the best ones with Blade Runner and M John Harrison's works, however, I think with tabletop RPGs, it's all about finding the right balance between known to all and implied. As I have written about previously , I also think it is very helpful for players to have a basic understanding of the world they are playing in, but these two things need not be in conflict. Hyperdiegesis is not about the blank spots on the map, but rather about the "known unknowns". Hyperdiegesis, as I have understood it, is about putting placing things in the consciousness of the players without elaborating. Rather than empty space, the map may have the "Lower Marlborough Lake of Fire", which has only been visited by the most daring adventurers. If the player characters (or indeed the players) wish to know m...

Toppling the pillars of the OSR: against lethality

Image
  One of the accepted wisdoms in the OSR (as codified in e.g. the Principia Apocrypha ), as well at the NSR (as defined by Yochai Gal or Pandatheist) is that lethality is good, and a core component of OSR/NSR play, because it means that player choice has real consequence. I do not entirely disagree with this, but I also do not entirely agree. My opinion aligns more with Pandatheist's follow-up post , arguing that "consequential" would be a better term. Perhaps my brain is poisoned with modern "trad" ideology, but when playing longer campaigns rather than one-shots, I find that the characters tend to evolve beyond vehicle's for the players' problem solving, developing interesting quirks and personalities that it would be a shame to lose because of an unlucky dice-roll (because that is one OSR tenet I do still believe in - the sanctity of the dice result). A dramatic death because of calculated risk gone wrong, or a heroic last stand against an ogre whil...

Power Word Magic

Image
  I often struggle with the depiction of Magic in RPGs, and I was prompted by a recent exchange on Bluesky with Josh of Rise up Comus to share some of my thoughts in the form of a blog post.  Magic in stories is often free-form, and while its power is usually limited, its application rarely is. In RPGs however, magic is often quantified in very specific spells, that do one single thing (at least in the paradigm of games descended from DnD). One particular egregious example is the iconic Fireball spell of fifth edition D&D, every part of it is very proscribed, you always throw a fireball of exactly the same strength (unless you upcast it). If you play the game rules-as-written, it is likely that your wizard can cast fireballs, but is unable to magically light a candle without burning the house down. Contrast for instance with the Fire Bolt spell, which essentially does the same thing, throw fire", but weaker. Again, your wizard might be able to cast Fireball, but not t...

Rules are a Safety Tool

Image
  I have recently been reading Fabula Ultima (more thoughts on that in a future post), and one thing that struck me is how often the rules text emphasises to not deviate from the rules-as-written unless everybody consents. This feels like a departure from the tabletop culture of allowing the GM to override the rules whenever it suits the game, or come up with their own house rules and expect the table to accept them. However, after further deliberation, it appears to me that this can be because the rules are a safety tool. Many people with more experience and knowledge and me have written about safety tools, so I will not go into deep detail here (see e.g. the TTRPG Safety Toolkit ), but one thing that seems generally true is that they only really work when everybody engages with them in good faith. They will not stop a problem player, who can easily ignore them, abuse them, or just generally cause an uncomfortable situation. What they are good for, is preventing those who want to...