Posts

Showing posts with the label review?

A Quick Look at a Big Book: Mythic Bastionland

Image
  After two iterations of the age of Industry, and once in the age of electricity, Chris McDowall, AKA Mr. Bastionland, has decided to tackle the age of heroic fantasy , of the Arthurian persuasion. Rather than the explorers of Into the Odd and debt-ridden failed careerists of Electric Bastionland, Mythic Bastionland concerns itself with Knights on a Quest. Like previous games set in the world of Bastion, the rules are light as they come, though with a little bit of added complexity in combat in the form of Feats and Gambits, as well as wrinkles related to weapon types, mounted combat, and mass combat. You know, knight stuff. Besides that, it's just the usual three-stat roll-under and no to-hit roll. It all sounds cool and fun. In total, all of this ends up filling a total of sixteen pages, including the GM advice for running the game. At the end of the book are 30 pages of play examples with commentary (the "Oddpocrypha"), with the rest (the majority of the book) are ...

A Quick Look at a Big Book: Cairn 2e

Image
Theodor Kittelsen 1870s, Photo: Nasjonalmuseet/Ivarsøy, Dag Andre   Once again, I am stretching the definition of "big book", firstly because the Cairn 2e books are not that big, at least compared to chonkers like His Majesty the Worm or The Hidden Isle , and secondly, because I am actually looking at TWO books: the Player's Guide and the Warden's Guide. There were in fact several more books in the box set, but most of those were also Players Guides. For the purposes of this review, I will cover the idea of the box a bit, but mainly focus on the contents of these two "core books", rather than the adventures. The second edition of Cairn is, like the first, written by Yochai Gal. The books have beautiful cover art by Bruno Prosaiko and interior illustrations by Amanda Lee Frank and Keny Widjaja. I have played a little bit of Cairn 1e (a single session in fact, unless my memory betrays me), so while I have a passing familiarity, I am not deeply enmeshed in ...

A Quick Look at a Big Book: The Hidden Isle

Image
  Hot on the heels of my previous review (of the down and dirty game of criminals, Swyvers ) comes another look at an even bigger book! This time, the tarot-based Forged in the Dark game The Hidden Isle with design and writing by Daniel Adams and James Patton , and art by Eliot Baum and Viv Tanner , published by the Austrian Causa Creations under their Sefirot brand. Evolved from the background lore of their previous board game offering, Sefirot , the game revolves around around Agents from the fictional Dioscoria, the titular Hidden Isle . The book is 190 pages of content, roughly A4 sized, and full of beautiful art. Set in what is ostensibly our real world with a dash of magic (inspired by the real beliefs of people at the time) on top, players take the role of agents sent by the Dioscorian government to meddle in the affairs of the rest of the world. Dioscoria itself is presented as a bit of an imperfect utopia: a multicultural haven of enlightenment and tolerance in an other...

A Quick Look at a Big Book: Swyvers

Image
Once again I have read a book. Swyvers is not the biggest of books, but it's a nice hardback and thus not a zine, and as we all know "Zine" and "Big book" are the only two types of RPG. Swyvers is written by Luke Gearing with art by David Hoskins , published by Melsonian Arts Council . I backed the Kickstarter for the fancy deluxe version, so this is the version I have read. To the best of my knowledge, the only difference between this and the standard hardcover, is that this one has shiny gold foil (making it a more enticing bit of loot for anyone who would burgle me, I guess). The book has a total of 95 pages of content, written by Luke Gearing at his nastiest, accompanied by David Hoskins' excellent art, bringing Luke's dark fantastic Britain to life. Swyvers is a book full of tables, and this is a good thing, since this is also where the work shines brightest. Gearing's writing is darkly funny, leaving me unable to suppress my chuckles at sever...

A quick look at a big book: Infærnum

Image
  While calling Infærnum a big book is perhaps a stretch, the lavish 192 page hardback is certainly not a zine, and these are obviously the only two categories of book and thus it must be a big one. Published by Mind's Vision , Infaernum was originally written in (Brazilian) Portuguese by Caio Romero with graphic design by Raul Rinaldi.  Unfortunately, I think the game suffers from being a translation, sentences are often clunky and unusually phrased in a way that does not feel like an intentional stylistic choice. This is a huge shame, as the book looks great, there has definitely been a significant investment in the presentation, so it would be great as if the crowdfunding could also have paid for another editing pass on the text. Fortunately it is generally clear, so it presents no obstacle to reading and playing the game, it just does not read particularly naturally. The version I read was the deluxe Apocalypse Edition, which is a gorgeous tome, full of colours and with g...

Zine Zone: Swineheart Motel

Image
  This December, I am participating in the Covert Critic blogging extravaganza, as celebrated by the bloggers nesting in the Prismatic Wasteland Discord server, inspired by Clayton Notestine's 2024 Gifts for RPG Designers . This is a very fun exercise, and has me reading things I otherwise might not have picked up. Today: Swineheart Motel by Ty Pitre, AKA Mindstorm Press . Swineheart Motel is a system-neutral horror adventure for modern settings, set in and around a roadside motel deep in the forests of northern America. A podcaster has gone missing (the horror!) and the players are tasked with finding him. This is all contained in a 40 page zine, to the best of my knowledge only available digitally. Art is sparse, but what's there is bespoke and good. Instead of more spot art, many pages have little hand-written quotes, possibly attributed to the missing podcaster, though this is unclear. What is beyond doubt, however, is that they work well for setting the scene with their ...

Reality Check: Songbirds 3e

Image
  It is said that no plan survives contact with reality, and I find that the same is often true of RPG rulesets. Of course, one can make a concerted effort to follow the rules as written, but in many cases, you will end up with your own table's version of the game, having discarded some bits of rules that did not click with you, and added some house rules of your own. I have been running Songbirds 3e by snow roughly weekly for most of the year, and in this post, I will try to sum up my experiences with playing it, rather than just what's in the book. Songbirds is, in its bones, a very simple system, relying to a large extent on vibes as its selling point. Fortunately, the vibes are impeccable, and absolutely managed to sell me on the game. At its core are four attributes, each with its associated skills tracked with 5e style proficiency. Checks are standard d20+modifier vs DC rolls, though unlike 5e attributes only have a single value acting as their modifier. Combat is done ...

A Quick Look at a Big Book: Fabula Ultima

Image
  Having read through another Big Book , I am here to offer my thoughts my thoughts once again. This time I have read Fabula Ultima , written by Emanuele Galletto and published by Italian outfit Need Games! Originally in Italian, but in English since 2022. Compared to His Majesty the Worm, my previous Big Book , this one is physically much smaller. However, the text feels much denser with less art and whitespace on the pages, so I would not be surprised if the word counts were at least comparable. This poses no problem, however, as the layout design is impeccable, making the book a smooth read. Similarly to The Worm, this seems like a book with a singular purpose: where The Worm wanted you to have fun making and playing in megadungeons, Fabula Ultima seeks to emulate the JRPG genre of video games. This is a clearly stated goal to the extent that the cover calls it a TTJRPG. I am not extremely experienced with the genre, but I have played a few and absorbed enough knowledge throug...

Zine zone: Cloud Empress

Image
  It's Mothership month , and that's as good a kick in the backside as any to finally get around to reading Cloud Empress . I ramble a bit about zines in general at the start, so if you're not interested in that and just want to get straight into some juicy imago flesh, just skip the next two paragraphs. Back in early 2023, I came across Cloud Empress  on Kickstarter , and I was quick to back it based on the strength of the art and the pitch. Later that year, impressively close to schedule, I received a little plastic bag full of zines. They ended up on my RPG shelf, squeezed between a bunch of hardbacks, until I later established a Zine Box, where they were equally, if not more hidden. I was always excited by the concepts presented in the game, but the jury is still out on zines for me. I really want to like them, because they allow for small products taking big swings, and should in theory be much more affordable than the big fancy hardbacks. However, I always hit two sna...

A quick look at a big book: His Majesty the Worm

Image
  A "problem" that I imagine affects many of us is that it is much easier to find the time to read, than to play. Fortunately reading is still an enjoyable pastime. In this (intended) series, I write up my impressions from a read-through of the book, with all the caveats that come with that. The first entry in this series is Josh McCrowell 's highly anticipated Big Book RPG His Majesty The Worm . Hopefully soon available again. At first glance, the game looks like OSR fare: desperate adventurers venturing into the megadungeon in search of fame and fortune. That is, until you look closer at the mechanics, which are different from any OSR game I have ever seen. Coming in with some familiarity with RPGs, The Worm reveals itself to be a different beast entirely, as if someone attempted to reconstruct the OSR dungeon experience from first principles using only the fiction, while rejecting the mechanical baggage of D&D. I was not surprised to hear Brad Kerr of Between Two C...